The Tribunal is an statutory body established to consider defence honours and awards matters.

An individual is able to apply directly to the Tribunal for an independent review of a decision of the Department of Defence concerning eligibility for a defence honour, defence award, or foreign award.

The Government is also able to refer general eligibility issues to the Tribunal for inquiry and recommendation.

POWERS OF THE TRIBUNAL

Part VIIIC of the Defence Act 1903 sets out the Tribunal’s powers.

Reviews

In reviewing eligiblity for a defence award (such as a campaign or long service award) and foreign awards the Tribunal is able to affirm a decision, revoke a decision, substitute a new decision or vary a decision.

In reviewing eligibility for defence honours (such as a gallantry or distinguished service award) the Tribunal may make recommendations to Government to affirm, revoke, substitute or vary the Department’s initial decision.

Inquiries

At the conclusion of an inquiry the Tribunal will provide a report to Government outlining its findings and any recommendations.

TRIBUNAL CHAIR AND MEMBERS

MR MARK SULLIVAN AO

Mr Mark Sullivan was appointed as the Chair of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal on 23 November 2014. Mr Sullivan has over a 40-year public sector and business career performed in a wide range of senior management roles, including as Managing Director of the ACT Government’s ACTEW Corporation Limited (2008-2014); Secretary of the Departments of Veterans Affairs (2004-2008) and Family and Community Services (2001-2004) and was CEO of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission from 1999 to 2001. Before then he was a Deputy Secretary of the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs for more than ten years.

MR DAVID ASHLEY AM

Mr Ashley enlisted in the Australian Army in 1979. In a career that spanned over 36 years, Mr Ashley held a range of positions, including Regimental Sergeant Major of the Australian Army. Mr Ashley retired from the Army in 2015.

BRIGADIER MARK BORNHOLT AM (RETD)

Brigadier Mark Bornholt was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in August 2014.

Brigadier Bornholt held a range of senior positions during his 32 year Army career including Commandant of the Royal Military College Duntroon. He had operational tours in the Middle East where he was commended for distinguished service.

After retiring from the Army in 2009 he became the Chief Executive Officer of a business unit of a publicly listed company. Brigadier Bornholt has also been a Services member on the Veterans’ Review Board, is a Director of the Royal Australian Regiment Foundation and provides consultancy services to business and industry.

REAR ADMIRAL JAMES GOLDRICK AO, CSC, RAN (RETD)

Rear Admiral Goldrick was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in 2015.

Rear Admiral Goldrick joined the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) in 1974 as a 15 year old Cadet Midshipman. As a Principal Warfare Officer, he saw sea service around the world with the RAN and on exchange with the Royal Navy. He commanded HMA Ships Cessnock and Sydney (twice) and the RAN task group and the multinational interception operation in the Persian Gulf.

Shore appointments included chief staff officer to the Chief of Navy, Director General Military Strategy and Commandant of the Australian Defence Force Academy. As a Rear Admiral, he served as Commander Border Protection Command and later as Commander of the Australian Defence College. He retired from full time service in the RAN in 2012. Awarded the Conspicuous Service Cross in 2001 and made a Member of the Order of Australia in 2004, he became an Officer in the Order in the 2013 Australia Day Honours List.

Rear Admiral Goldrick is an internationally published academic with a strong record of historical and maritime strategic publications. He has an Honorary Doctorate of Letters from the University of NSW and is a Councillor of the Navy Records Society (UK), an Overseas Corresponding Member of the UK Society for Nautical Research and a member of the Naval Historical Society of Australia.

MS NAIDA ISENBERG

Ms Naida Isenberg was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in August 2014.

Ms Isenberg is currently a Senior Member of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, and its NSW equivalent, and the Migration and Refugee Tribunals. She is a Lieutenant Colonel in the Army Reserves, and serves on the board of the War Widows’ Guild (NSW) and formally served on the Veterans’ Review Board.

Ms Isenberg has a long legal background at a senior level in both the Commonwealth and NSW governments, as well as in the private sector.

MS JOSEPHINE LUMB

Ms Lumb was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in August 2017.

Ms Lumb is currently a part-time member of the Veterans’ Review Boards. She has 20 years’ experience in both legal and policy roles across a range of Commonwealth Government agencies.

Ms Lumb worked with the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade from 1998-2011, including serving on diplomatic posting in Chile from 2001-2004. She also served on the Defence Abuse Response Taskforce in 2014-15.

MR GRAHAM ‘BERT’ MOWBRAY

Mr Mowbray served for four years on the Federal Magistrates Court (now the Federal Circuit Court of Australia). Prior to this Mr Mowbray served on the Administrative Appeals Tribunal after working in the position of General Counsel (Immigration) with the Australian Government Solicitor for eight years. His early years were spent in various legal positions with the Commonwealth Government.

Mr Mowbray was the Presiding Member of the Australian Wine Industry Code Administration Committee, was President of the Weston Creek Cricket Club, and remains a Member of the National Appeal Panel of the Uniting Church in Australia.

AIR VICE-MARSHAL A. JOHN QUAIFE AM (RETD)

Air Vice-Marshal Quaife was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in 2015.

Air Vice-Marshal Quaife joined the Royal Australian Air Force as a Cadet Pilot in 1975. He graduated to fly fast jet aircraft, qualified as a Fighter Combat instructor and held a number of command postings, including at unit (No 77 squadron); Group (Air Combat Group); and Command (Air Commander Australia). Other appointments included as Director Combined Air Operations Centre in the Middle East Area of Operations and as the Head of Capability Systems in the Defence Materiel Organisation. After retiring from the Air Force in 2008, Air Vice-Marshal Quaife became the General Manager Aviation Solutions for BAE Systems Australia, retiring from that position in November 2014.

MS JANE SCHWAGER AO

Ms Schwager was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in 2015.

Ms Schwager is currently a non-judicial member of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal. She is also a nationally accredited Mediator in the area of alternative dispute resolution. In previous roles Ms Schwager has led both State government departments and non-profit organisations. She was the Chief Executive Officer of The Benevolent Society. She was also the Chief Executive Officer of the Parklands Foundation at Olympic Park in Sydney. Ms Schwager has also sat on a number of government and non-profit boards, including Taxation Board of Australia; Campbell Page Ltd; Nonprofit Australia; and Social Ventures.

During her time in State government she headed the NSW Department of the Ageing and Disability, the NSW Social Policy Directorate, and held senior roles in NSW Treasury, Community Services and Health.

MS ANNE TRENGOVE

Ms Anne Trengove was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in August 2017.

Ms Trengove is currently a Senior Member of the Veteran’s Review Board, having been appointed in August 2014. She was admitted to practice law in 1996. She has appeared as prosecuting counsel for the Office of Public Prosecutions, SA in the Supreme and District Courts. She also worked in private practice and on behalf of the Ministry of Defence in London, UK for the Treasury Solicitor.

Ms Trengove has been a Reserve Legal Officer in the Royal Australian Air Force for 20 years and holds the rank of Group Captain and the position of Adelaide Panel Leader.

MAJOR GENERAL SIMONE WILKIE AO (RETD)

Major General Simone Wilkie was appointed as a Member of the Defence Honours and Awards Appeals Tribunal in 2019.

Major General Simone Wilkie retired from the Army in 2018 after 35 years of service. She had operational tours to Cambodia, Iraq and Afghanistan where she was the national commander in 2011/12.

She is the Chair of Defence Technologies at Deakin University, a Commissioner of the Australian Football League, and a Non-Executive Director of AFL SportsReady, the Australian American Leadership Dialogue, and the Beaufort Group.